HLR VS SUPPLEMENTAL CLAIM LANE CHECK

Use Higher-Level Review when the argument is that VA made an error based on the evidence already in the file.
Use Supplemental Claim when the fix depends on new and relevant evidence.
Use Board when the issue needs Board-level review, testimony, or a Board evidence lane.
Verify current VA rules and deadlines before filing.

Questions:
Decision date:
Issue:
Did VA already have the evidence needed? yes / no / not sure
Are you trying to add new evidence? yes / no
Did VA miss favorable evidence already listed or in the file? yes / no / not sure
Did VA use a weak or incomplete exam? yes / no / not sure
Do you have new medical records, buddy statements, DBQ, nexus letter, or logs? yes / no
Is testimony important? yes / no / not sure

Likely lane to investigate:
Why:
Risk:
Next action:

Prompt to use:
Review this decision and tell me whether the problem fits Higher-Level Review, Supplemental Claim, Board appeal, increased-rating claim, or another route. Only recommend HLR if the issue is an error based on evidence already in the file. If new evidence is needed, tell me what to build for a Supplemental Claim. Do not guarantee outcomes.
